Why I Hate Thrifting: Junk, Overwhelm, & Overconsumption
It’s an unpopular opinion, especially in the sustainable living space, but I don’t enjoy thrift shopping.
While I know it’s a big aspect of many eco-conscious people’s lifestyle, it’s not for me.
I used to enjoy shopping secondhand. I found some unique pieces over the years and furnished my college apartment with secondhand furniture.
Thrifted Disney button down I bought about ten years ago
But over a decade later, thrifting just doesn’t hit the same for me. Let’s get into it!
There is Too Much Fast Fashion
Back when I was thrfiting in high school, I felt like it was easier to find high quality pieces.
Today thrift stores have received such an influx in fast fashion (and cheaply made home goods) from people disposing of unwanted items, I feel like it’s harder to find pieces that are actually well made.
Whenever I purchase a new item, how long it will last me is something I’m always thinking of.
Super high quality denim jacket I thrifted over ten years ago! Still have it in 2025!
It can be overwhelming
Going off of my point of there being more junk and fast fashion, I get overwhelmed in secondhand shops. As a neurodivergent person, thrift shops can be a lot.
And maybe it’s getting older and my lack of patience, but sorting through all of the junk can make me feel anxious.
There is still a lot of overconsumption
While buying secondhand is definitley a more sustainable choice when compared to buying new, I think the increasing trendiness of thrift shopping still encourages overconsumption.
Some people continue to buy more because it is secondhand and a “more sustianable way of shopping.”
But I think the most sustainable option is to pause and ask ourselves if we really need an item before buying it.
Other Ways to Shop Secondhand
Buying secondhand items can be a great way to practice underconsumption, but finding the best way to go about that is different for each individual person.
While I don’t love shopping secondhand in person, I have been known to look online. I mainly use Poshmark.
And I’ve purchased secondhand items from neighbors! But going to the physical thrift store isn’t for me!
Secondhand shelf I purchased from a neighbor
I’ve also created a list of the top online thrift shops for people who might feel similar.
More Thrifting Content Sustainable People Will Enjoy Reading:
MEET THE AUTHOR
Emily Waddell is the founder of The Honest Consumer. She has always been passionate about business for good and has a Bachelor degree in Social Entrepreneurship. She currently lives in Seattle where she practices imperfect sustainability. When she’s not writing, Emily enjoys supporting small businesses, clean eating, & practicing slow living. Learn more about Emily’s journey starting The Honest Consumer.
For more ethical & sustainable tips be sure to explore more conscious lifestyle blog posts, follow The Honest Consumer on social media, subscribe to our newsletter, & check out the Ethical & Sustainable Brand Directory.